Virtual Reality in Autism

Impairments in social communication skills and deficient social and emotional competence are thought to be core deficits of children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD). In recent years, several assistive technologies, particularly Virtual Reality (VR), have been adapted to help in the evaluation and training of emotional reactivity and social skills training in this patient population. These platforms can help capture real-time responses to VR social interaction scenes.

In the past few years, VR technology has undergone a transformation by merging with new inexpensive systems like Oculus Rift, and now has the chance to transform from an “expensive toy” for entertainment into a functional technology for clinical research in autism. VR systems have a huge potential as a viable tool for a wide range of clinical and research applications that are not limited exclusively to exposure applications (e.g., for phobias treatment). Rights for Oculus Rift VR system was recently acquired by Facebook and soon it will be in a mass production and widely available to prospective users at a very affordable price.

1*s5Lk0l5YHJqb2-w9ZLK45g

There is a strong rationale for the integration of VR with real-time psychophysiological monitoring for advanced cognitive and affective neuroscience research. In the area of psychophysiology the technology for non-invasive recording of physiological activity is used to investigate and understand correlates of cognitive processes and emotional states. The use of VR now allows for the measurement of interaction within a more realistic and dynamic 3D environment using precise emotional and socially meaningful stimulus delivery within more naturalistic scenarios well-matched for the specifics of autism research and treatment.

There are only a few reported VR studies in ASD. These studies have found that VR can be utilized in ASD as a learning tool, to teach safety skills, to engage their interest, monitor eye gaze, aid learning of pretend play, and more accurately interpret emotions of VR avatars. It is of interest to note that VR applications were also used in the past as therapeutic tools to help people with autism to recognize emotions and improve their mentalizing (i.e., theory-of-mind) or other businesses in adolescents with ASD. The VR software provided users an opportunity to maneuver an avatar and engage in simplified interactions, such as finding a place to sit, placing an order to a waiter, etc. Parsons et al. (2002,2004) investigated the use of the virtual café in teenagers with ASD having only mild impairments. When compared to matched controls, the ASD group had difficulties maneuvering avatars. The ASD children were reported to engage in the virtual environment as a representation of reality. A qualitative case-study of two adolescents was conducted to further investigate the use of VR in ASD interventions (Parsons et al., 2004) and results indicated that the ASD adolescents interpreted the VR as life-like, while enjoying the task and discussions with the real-life facilitator seated next to them. A subsequent study utilized trained raters to quantify social judgment and reasoning in 6 adolescents using Likert scales at three time points. These preliminary studies have demonstrated that individuals with ASD can use, appropriately understand, enjoy, and practice social interactions in VR settings.

While these previous VR studies showed some promise and perspective, they were limited in several ways. First, the VR software in those studies used technical and non-natural ways to activate feedback on programmed social decisions, e.g., keyboard, mouse or joystick to click on the screen. Second, measurements of social performance over time was limited to few experimental indices and raters evaluations. Measurement of social skills and social competence behavior is difficult, especially since few social measures are published or standardized. A further complication is the lack of sensitive measures of physiological responses to emotional stimuli and social cues. The need for reliable and valid tools to measure social cognition and function remains a challenge, particularly for adolescents and young adults with ASD. Other limitations of prior studies were the absence of psychophysiological measurements, a reduced flexibility of the skills training programs, and an inability from the participants to dynamically interact based on their emotional status. A majority of these VR social skills training studies were limited to children, used simplistic VR scripts.  Only few studies were conducted on adolescents and young adults with ASD, the population that might benefit most from ability to use VR for evaluation and training of more advanced social skills. In addition to the listed limitations, it must be specifically noted that some of the studies cited above were “virtual simulators” on regular 2D screen computers, rather than actual immersive helmet based VR studies, and such studies cannot even qualify to use VR terminology in their titles.

In summary, VR can become a useful tool for conducting controlled experimental trials where precise emotive or social stimuli can be delivered to participants with ASD, while perceptual, attentional, and emotional responses can be objectively recorded using psychophysiological measures such as skin conductance level (SCL), heart rate variability (HRV) indices, respiration rate, electromyogram (EMG), eye-tracking, and other similar peripheral variables, and potentially also electroencephalogram (EEG) and event-related potentials (ERP). Unlike other therapeutic test options, such as role-playing, VR provides for a more realistic experience in a safe, controllable manner that allows for repeated practice and exposure, which is a key element in any training or occupational treatment.  The flexibility of the VR environment, without the added stress of face-to-face interactions with an instructor, may be very appealing to individuals with ASD. All of the above stated advantages of VR-based psychophysiological profiling system suggest that VR may prove to be a more effective platform for functional assessment of social skills, social cognition, emotional and social reciprocity in children with ASD compared to other diagnostic tools. This requires a careful examination and review of the current state of VR applications in autism research and treatment.

References

Parsons, S., Mitchell, P., & Leonard, A. (2004). The use and understanding of virtual environments by adolescents with autistic spectrum disorders. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 34(4), 449-466.

Parsons, S., & Mitchell, P. (2002). The potential of virtual reality in social skills training for people with autistic spectrum disorders. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 46(5), 430-443.

A general review on this subject can be found in Bellani, M., Fornasari L., Chittaro L., & Brambilla, P. (2011). Virtual reality in autism: state of the art. Epidemiology Psychiatry Sciences, 20(3), 235-238.

One response to “Virtual Reality in Autism

  1. In the future VR possibily can reveal as a powerfull tool to learn social interaction styles. At present, it has an important handicap: it only can develope a short spectre of situations, an all of them are limited by fixed patterns and a scarce choice´s ability. Unfortunately, the real social interaction is more complicated and impredictable than a VR role play.

    I think that VR technology can be used as a source of interactions with real people (I have read about the online courses and events in Second Life virtual universe, for example). This would be an accessible and “secure” way to practice social relations. Much better than internet discussion forums, I believe… XD

    But I still dream about the creation of a VR simplified world (more schematic, more slow) for low functionality children with autism, like an Isaac Asimov´s science-fiction tale. This digital universe could be more compicated progressively, serving as a way of underestanding the real world and providing the possibility of learning to navigate on it. In this fantastic world, kids could play with a pink ball in a blue room in the begining… and eventually would converse in a virtual restaurant with some digital characters guided by experiencied therapist who are not yet born.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s